Brandeis Legal Realism
He spent the next year studying how the life insurance industry works, often writing articles and giving speeches about its findings, describing their practices at one point as „legalized theft.“ [13]: 76-77 In 1906, he concluded that life insurance was a „bad deal for the vast majority of policyholders,“ largely because of the inefficiency of the industry. He also learned that a misunderstood clause in the low-wage workers policy allowed the policy to be cancelled if they missed a payment, and that most policies became obsolete; Only one in eight insureds received benefits, resulting in high profits for insurance companies. [9] Brandeis found, however, that previous Supreme Court decisions limited contractual rights where the contract had „a real or substantial connection to public health or welfare.“ He therefore decided that the best way to present the case would be to demonstrate, through a multitude of facts in the workplace, „a clear link between the health and morality of the workers“ and the hours they had to work. To achieve this, he submitted what is now known as the „brandeis letter.“ It was much shorter than traditional briefings, but contained more than a hundred pages of documentation, including reports from social workers, medical findings, observations from labor inspectors, and other expert reports that together showed a preponderance of evidence showing that „when women worked long hours, it was destructive to their health and morals.“ [13]: 120-121 The letter was filled with social research and data to demonstrate public interest in a ten-hour limit on women`s working hours. Its mission proved decisive in Muller v. Oregon, the first Supreme Court decision to accept the legitimacy of a scientific investigation into social conditions, in addition to the legal facts involved in a case. [36] In the 1890s, Brandeis began to question his views on American industrialism, Write Klebanov and Jonas. He became aware of the growing number of huge companies capable of dominating entire industries. He began to lose confidence that the economic system was able to regulate them for the benefit of the public. As a result, he denounced „fierce competition“ and worried about monopolies. He was also concerned about the fate of the workers and sympathized more with the workers` movement. [9] His previous litigation had convinced him that the concentration of economic power could have a negative impact on a free society. [28]: 139 Beginning in 1890, he helped develop the concept of the „right to privacy“ by writing an article in the Harvard Law Review with this title,[3] and was recognized by jurist Roscoe Pound as „nothing less than adding a chapter to our law.“ He went on to publish a book called Other People`s Money and How the Bankers Use It, in which he suggested ways to limit the power of big banks and money trusts.
He fought powerful corporations, monopolies, public corruption and mass consumption, which he found harmful to American values and culture. He also became active in the Zionist movement, seeing it as a solution to anti-Semitism in Europe and Russia, while being a means of „reviving the Jewish spirit.“ In 1934, Brandeis had another legal confrontation with Morgan, this time over securities regulatory laws. J. P. Morgan`s resident economist, Russell Leffingwell, found it necessary to remind his banker Tom Lamont of who they would be dealing with: Brandeis defined modern notions of the individual right to privacy in an groundbreaking article he published with his partner Warren in the Harvard Law Review of December 15, 1890, on „The Right to Privacy.“ Inspired by anger over the offensive publicity surrounding the Warren family`s social activities, she proposed a new legal concept that had a lasting influence. Relying on various analogies in the law of slander, literary property, and eavesdropping, Brandeis argued that the central, though inarticulate, interest in these areas was an interest in personal integrity, „the right to be left alone,“ which should be protected from invasion except for an overriding reason of public welfare. Brandeis saw emotions as a positive expression of human nature and therefore wanted privacy protection for them as protection from the oppression of the human mind. In 1889, Brandeis entered a new phase of his legal career when his partner Samuel Warren retired from their partnership to take over his recently deceased father`s paper business.[20] Brandeis then took over business with the help of colleagues, two of whom became partners in his new company in 1897: Brandeis, Dunbar and Nutter.
[11]: 82-86 According to legal historian Scott Powe, much of the opposition to Brandeis` appointment also stemmed from „blatant anti-Semitism.“ [45] Taft accused Brandeis of using his Judaism to curry political favors, and Wickersham described Brandeis followers and Taft critics as „a group of Hebrew newcomers.“ [47] Senator Henry Cabot Lodge complained privately, „If Brandeis were not Jewish and Jewish German, he would never have been appointed.“ [48] Those who supported his membership in the court were equally numerous and influential. Brandeis had many friends who admired his legal acumen in the struggle for progressive causes. They launched a national advertising campaign that marginalized anti-Semitic insults in the legal profession. [49] Supporters included lawyers, social workers, and reformers with whom he had worked on cases, and they testified enthusiastically on his behalf. Roscoe Pound, a Harvard law professor, told the committee that „Brandeis was one of the great lawyers“ and predicted that one day he would be „among the best to sit on the Supreme Court bench.“ Other lawyers who supported him told the committee that he had „angered some of his clients because he made a diligent effort to be fair to both parties in a case.“ [46]: 208 Wayne McIntosh writes about him: „In our national legal temple, some figures have received an almost Olympic reverence. Part of this legal pantheon is Louis D. Brandeis – especially since Brandeis was much more than a great judge. He was also a social reformer, a legal innovator, a trade union fighter and a Zionist leader. And it was as a judge that his concepts of privacy and freedom of expression ultimately led, albeit posthumously, to virtual legal changes that still reverberate today. Former Judge William O. Douglas wrote, „He helped America grow to greatness through the dedications he made his life.
[4] The public is often insufficiently represented or not represented at all. This is a condition of great injustice to the public. As a result, many bills are passed in the Legislative Assembly that would not have become law if the public interest had been fairly represented. Those of you who are attracted to this profession can be sure that you will find in it an opportunity of utility that is probably incomparable. There is an appeal to the legal profession to do a great job for this country. [19] In a letter during his time at Harvard, he wrote about his „desperate desire for more law“ and the „almost ridiculous pleasure I get from discovering or inventing a legal theory.“ He referred to the law as his „beloved“ and held it, which he could not break. [14] During his time at Harvard, jurisprudence underwent a shift in methodology from traditional, memorized, „black letter“ jurisprudence to a more flexible and interactive Socratic method that used earlier cases as a basis for discussion to teach students legal thought.