Current Legal Issues in Education 2019

This influential case regarding First Amendment rights and free speech for public school teachers set a precedent for public servants to have the opportunity to speak out on matters of public interest, even as state or government employees. Yet the rights of public sector employees continue to be challenged in the U.S. justice system. Ethical decisions take place every day in our classrooms. Often, you may believe that treating students equally is an ethical approach. But when you walk into a classroom, you may notice that a teacher calls a shy student rather than another student who usually dominates the discussion. Is it the same thing? The teacher clearly treats the two students differently. This is what we call good teaching practices in education. The NEA Code of Ethics guides your teaching behavior by placing your students at the center of your practice. Always remember that you need to treat all students the same way, not necessarily the same way. At school, educators have a responsibility that the courts call „in loco parentis“ or „in the place of parents“. This means that it is the responsibility of educators to make judgments similar to those a parent might make with respect to the safety of children. Because an educator is legally responsible for the safety of children under his or her supervision, a teacher is considered negligent if he or she fails to protect a child from injury or harm.

In another case, B.H. and K.M. v. Easton Area School District (2013), students were suspended for wearing bracelets that showed support for breast cancer awareness. In this case, the judge ruled in favor of the students. The school district then took the case to the Supreme Court, but the court refused to hear the case, stating that the message on the bracelet did not use obscene language and did not interfere with the purpose of the education. The First Amendment requires schools to see the views of all students equally, as long as they are not obscene or disturbing, regardless of the message expressed (Sherwin, 2017). On May 6, 2020, the U.S. Department of Education („ED“ or „the Department“) released the long-awaited Title IX final regulations, which have a significant impact on schools across the country – both K-12 and higher education institutions. This document identifies some of the key differences between the requirements for K-12 and higher education institutions, as set out in the ministry`s final regulation and related commentary.

In 2005, a 13-year-old special education student was called out of class and interrogated by police officers with school officers about burglaries in the neighborhood. Her parents were not contacted, and her Miranda rights were not read, such as the right to remain silent, leave the room, or have access to a lawyer. The child confessed to the crime, but then tried to suppress his confession because he received no indication of his rights while in police custody in the school`s conference room. This case, J.D.B. v. North Carolina (2011), was then heard by the Supreme Court, where it ruled that age should have been taken into account in deciding whether the student was in custody on school grounds. The judges further explained that there are psychological differences between an adult and a child, and when the police are involved in the interrogation of students, they must use „common sense“ because of differences in children`s development. In this case, Miranda warnings should have been applied in a manner appropriate to the student before he or she was questioned. In discharging the obligation to the student, the educator cannot unreasonably deny the student access to different perspectives (National Education Association, 2019, para.

8). This judgment was later challenged in 1986, when a student used what the school called „vulgar“ language in a speech at a meeting. The student was reprimanded by the school and the student sued the school on the grounds that his constitutional right to freedom of expression had been violated. The case was taken to the U.S. Supreme Court, where the Court in Bethel School District No. 403 v. Fraser (1986) concluded that a school is not required to allow offensive or disruptive speech on school grounds at a school-sanctioned event because offensive language or language interferes with the school`s educational mission and is not appropriate for a school environment.