El Sistema De La Prueba Legal O Tasada

As noted earlier, the fact that the judge had greater discretion did not mean that he or she could decide arbitrarily. Free appreciation will always be subject to the rules of logic, science and common experience, so that the discretion granted to the judge must not exceed these limits and must set out the grounds on which the decision taken is based. This system is currently recognized in most country codes related to civil law. Our 1993 Code of Civil Procedure recognizes this system of evaluation, and it is the basis of the fundamental right to evidence in a trial. That is, in evaluating evidence in accordance with the system of well-founded criticism, judges must take into account the knowledge provided by experts, the laws of logic, psychological principles, common sense, as well as the experiences that daily life has brought to everyone; Obviously, the elaboration of a decision is not an easy task, since it is a question of finally resolving the conflict raised, the judges are invested to make the decision, and only have to answer the controversial question raised by the prosecution and supported only by the evidence contained. Informed criticism requires a justification or justification for the decision, an expression of the reasons why it is decided in a certain way, and a reference to the evidence that was taken into account in arriving at a decision and its critical evaluation. In this system, a distinction was made between positive and negative legal evidence: (a) In the first case, the law stipulated that the judge had to consider the adversarial hypothesis as proven, even if it violated his conviction, which established an obligation of conviction or acquittal; while (b) in the second case, the law required that the judge could not consider the adversarial hypothesis as proven, even if it also violated his conviction and enforced an acquittal. This system was born in response to the curious abilities prevalent in the Middle Ages to protect the rights of the accused and force the judge to apply the rules of the balancing of evidence, their persuasive values being set out in the law. Portada » All articles » Systems of evaluating evidence and their relationship to the fundamental right to evidence: from the system of legal evidence to the system of free appreciation of evidence In recent years, people have been exposed to unpleasant experiences, testing was mainly life or death, survival being a way to show innocence[6].

None of the facts discussed were verified, but simply and simply an action was performed that resembled „throwing a coin in the air to give reason to one or the other or finding it guilty or innocent“[7]. Recourse was had to the deity, who expressed his opinion in favor of the one who had to endure the test set for each situation in order to prove the guilt or innocence of the person. For a complete development on this topic, the test and its scope, methods and definitions are explained, which will be useful for understanding and manipulating this material, its understanding and development of the following other concepts. It should be noted that these have been adapted to different procedural models, as in the case of legal or evaluated evidence (inquisitorial system); intimate persuasion (adversarial) and free or well-founded critical evaluation. Its working process was given as a result of the criteria adopted or discarded according to the moment when the discussion took place, and in particular taking into account the level of development of society, the conformation of the prosecution system and the model of the State`s penal policy (criterion of temporality and omnipresence). In the past, various pieces of evidence have been used to support the parties` claims in a trial. The evidence was evaluated by the legal acts (judges) in order to resolve the submitted conflict and make a final decision. Test evaluation systems have changed over time.

We find mainly two systems of evaluation of evidence, which are defined in our national codes: the system of legal or „evaluated“ evidence and the system of evaluation or free evaluation of evidence. This article focuses on the definition and development of the two systems for evaluating evidence and analysing its relationship to the fundamental procedural right of evidence. A system of evidence is the law that governs the form of investigation of facts in the process, which manifests itself in the forms and means by which a truth of the facts can be attained, and in the way in which those means are evaluated. This system allows us to know how the judge should formulate his conviction in light of the facts. This is also the fundamental basis for the amendments proposed at this stage of the plenary and the judgment on the evidentiary system, which I will discuss later. However, the evidentiary system is subject to significant changes and valuable creations in the field of law, in particular with regard to the introduction of modern methods of taking evidence; the introduction of new specific cases of appreciation in conscience or after well-founded criticisms, which occur, for example, in the concentrated process, which will be of great benefit; the extension of the concept of documentary evidence; the resolution of certain aspects of current issues, such as the preservation and evaluation of evidence obtained through voice recording or the use of chemical means to obtain the declaration; or the verification of the truth obtained during the examination by mechanical or chemical means; the establishment of the principle that there are no presumptions of law in criminal matters, etc. For a long time, the evaluation of submitted evidence was heavily regulated and restricted by the legislature. This rating system has been referred to as a legal system or „evaluated“. According to Michele Taruffo, „this system was based on the application of rules that determined a priori and generally the probative value of certain types of evidence“[2]. Thus, the rules that determined the value of evidence were abstract and general, so that they applied equally in all cases. It is this system of evaluation that had remarkable dominance in our 1912 Code of Civil Procedure. Indeed, it is assumed that this system was designed to limit the discretion of the judge, especially since it arose in a context where judges were considered corrupt or likely to be subject to it and their decisions did not necessarily concern justice and the protection of the rights of the individual.